Why the Highest Offer Isn’t Always the Best One in the Tampa Bay Real Estate Market
Real Estate
Real Estate
Most people assume that when it comes to selling a home in Tampa Bay, price is everything.
After all, isn’t the highest offer always the best one?
Not necessarily.
After more than two decades working in the Tampa Bay real estate market, I’ve learned something surprising:
Most sellers care more about certainty than squeezing out every last dollar.
Why? Because once you’ve seen enough deals fall apart at the eleventh hour — from financing hiccups and inspection surprises to closing delays — you realize sellers value one thing above all else: a smooth, reliable closing.
Here’s how Tampa Bay homebuyers can use that insight to craft offers that stand out — even in competitive markets.
When sellers compare offers, they’re not just looking at price.
They’re scanning for contingencies — those “what if” clauses that can stall or derail a deal.
Every contingency adds uncertainty:
Inspection contingency? The buyer could walk if repairs get messy.
Appraisal contingency? The lender might value the home lower than expected.
Financing contingency? The loan could fall through altogether.
💡 Pro Tip: Consider ordering a pre-inspection before submitting your offer. It shows initiative, reduces unknowns, and positions you as a serious, low-risk buyer.
The smoother your offer looks, the more comfortable the seller feels saying “yes” — even if another offer comes in slightly higher.
Sellers care just as much about how you’ll pay as they do about how much.
A strong financing package signals dependability. That includes:
A 20% (or higher) down payment
A trusted local lender known for closing on time
A clear pre-approval letter ready to share with the seller’s agent
In competitive markets like Tampa Bay, sellers (and their agents) often prefer offers backed by reliable local lenders over those from large, impersonal online institutions. A smooth, responsive lender can be the difference between a confident seller and a nervous one.
✅ Pro Move: Have your lender ready to take calls from the listing agent. Quick communication goes a long way toward winning trust.
An earnest money deposit is your chance to show commitment.
While typical deposits range from 1–3% of the purchase price, offering slightly more can help your offer stand out.
Think of it as putting skin in the game — a clear sign that you’re confident and serious about closing.
For the seller, it translates to:
“This buyer isn’t just interested — they’re invested.”
At the end of the day, sellers aren’t always chasing the biggest paycheck.
They’re chasing peace of mind.
They want to know the offer they accept will make it to the closing table — without drama, delays, or last-minute surprises.
If you’re buying a home in today’s Tampa Bay market, remember:
You don’t have to be the highest bidder to win.
You just have to be the most certain one.
Show up prepared.
Limit contingencies where possible.
Strengthen your financing.
Offer a solid earnest deposit.
Because while price may grab attention, certainty wins hearts.
📩 Thinking about making an offer?
Let’s build a winning strategy that gets sellers to say “yes.”
Contact John Pestalozzi Jr. at [email protected] or visit WestwardRealEstate.com to get started today.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
You’ve got questions and we can’t wait to answer them.